Geometry & Figures

Depth · one concept from first principles · step 2 of 4

When three lines fail to make a triangle

The two lines y=x+3y=x+3 and y=mx−1y=mx-1 meet at the point (4,7)(4, 7). A third line y=ax+5y=ax+5 is drawn. Find all values of the constant aa for which the three lines do not enclose a triangle. (mm is a constant.)

ExpressionsFunctions
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — List the ways three lines can fail: the third line is parallel to the first, parallel to the second, or passes through the point where the first two already meet. (Two lines can't coincide, since the y-intercepts 3, -1, 5 are all different.) First find m from the given crossing point, then turn each case into an equation for a.
1STEP 1

Find m

The line y=mx-1 passes through (4, 7).

7=4m-1 → m=2
2STEP 2

Case 1: all three meet at one point

If y=ax+5 also passes through (4, 7), the three crossing points collapse into one.

7=4a+5 → a=1/2
3STEP 3

Case 2: parallel to y = x + 3

Equal slopes with different y-intercepts (5 ≠ 3) means parallel, so those two never meet.

a=1
4STEP 4

Case 3: parallel to y = 2x - 1

Likewise, matching the slope m=2 makes the third line parallel to the second (5 ≠ -1).

a=2
5STEP 5

Collect the cases

Any other a gives two new crossings, different from (4, 7) and from each other, so a triangle forms.

a=1/2, 1, 2
Answer
a=1/2, 1, 2
Check a good value, a=0: y=5 meets y=x+3 at (2, 5) and y=2x-1 at (3, 5); with (4, 7) that is three distinct corners, a real triangle. So only the special values break it.
Takeaway

To make a triangle you need three different corners -- so hunt for the ways to lose a corner: parallel lines, or all three crossing at one spot.

  • Find m
  • Case 1: all three meet at one point
  • Case 2: parallel to y = x + 3
  • Case 3: parallel to y = 2x - 1
  • Collect the cases
Where next?
Another one like thissuggested

A parent dashboard for the family lives at sensimlab.com.

▶ Practice — 12 problems